When we think of the Super Bowl, we often remember the champions, the MVPs, and the highlight plays that clinched glory. While, some of the most incredible performances came from players on the losing side. Heartbreak overshadowed many efforts. These three athletes delivered under the brightest light, only to be forgotten in Super Bowl history.
Chris Matthews – Super Bowl XLIX (Seahawks vs. Patriots)

Chris Matthews is one of the most unlikely success stories in sports history. After going undrafted out of Kentucky in 2011, Matthews took his talents to the CFL. Where he became the league’s Rookie of the Year in 2012. That season caught the attention of several NFL teams. Soon after, while back home working security with his father—not at Foot Locker, contrary to the popular headline. The Seattle Seahawks would give him a shot.
He spent most of the 2014 season on the practice squad. Then came the NFC Championship Game. Matthews recovered a crucial onside kick that sparked the Seahawks’ miraculous comeback against the Packers.
Yet his true breakout came in Super Bowl XLIX. Suddenly, With zero career targets before that night, Matthews stunned the world with 109 receiving yards and a touchdown on the NFL’s biggest stage. His performance included two 40+ yard receptions that helped set up key scoring drives.
Unfortunately, his night—and possible MVP run—was overshadowed by Malcolm Butler’s game-sealing interception. While the Seahawks’ loss became a defining sports moment, Chris Matthews’ rise from anonymity to Super Bowl stardom deserves to be remembered.
Jake Delhomme – Super Bowl XXXVIII (Panthers vs. Patriots)

Jake Delhomme’s journey to the NFL is one of grit and patience. After going undrafted, bouncing around the league, even spending time in NFL Europe. Delhomme would sign with the Carolina Panthers in 2003. Quickly taking over for Rodney Peete in Week 1, he led the Panthers to an 11-5 record. Further proving himself with five fourth-quarter comebacks and seven game-winning drives.
The Panthers rolled into the playoffs, capped by a legendary double-overtime win over the Rams, sealed with a 69-yard touchdown to Steve Smith. A week later, they defeated the Eagles to earn a trip to Super Bowl XXXVIII.
Against the defending champion Patriots, Delhomme struggled early. After a fumble and a rough 1-for-9 start, he found his rhythm, launching a 39-yard touchdown to Steve Smith late in the first half. He ended the night with 323 yards and 3 touchdowns, including a then-Super Bowl-record 85-yard touchdown to Muhsin Muhammad.
In the final minutes, Delhomme orchestrated a clutch game-tying drive, only for Tom Brady and Adam Vinatieri to snatch the win. Despite the heartbreak, Delhomme proved he belonged, and for one night, out-dueled the best, even in defeat.
Kony Ealy – Super Bowl 50 (Panthers vs. Broncos)
Leading up to Super Bowl 50, MVP Cam Newton’s electrifying season and the Broncos’ historic defense, led by veterans and future Hall of Famers took over headlines. Along with Peyton Manning set to retire after the game. The stage was set for a classic.
Broncos defense, smothered Carolina’s offense. Sacking Newton six times, and forcing three Panther turnovers. Yet one Panther refused to go quietly.
Kony Ealy, a rotational defensive end, delivered one of the most dominant defensive performances in Super Bowl history. In just 23 snaps, Ealy racked up 3 sacks, 1 interception, and a forced and recovered fumble, becoming the first player ever to achieve that stat line in a Super Bowl.
His historic effort nearly turned the tide, but Denver’s defense was too much. While Von Miller took home MVP honors, Ealy’s name belongs in the Super Bowl record books, and his performance stands as one of the greatest ever on the biggest stage.
If you enjoyed this article please follow us here on MSN! Thank you for reading and have a great day!